Influencer Marketing Gone Wrong

Paul Harvey is with us with Influencer Marketing Gone Wrong sharing his marketing strategy using messenger chatbots and Instagram stories to promote his Amazon products

  • Whole new Amazon account for two new kids products
  • Didn’t want to do big giveaways so looked to launch with only 40% off
  • Aimed to generate mass traffic to the Messenger chat bot
  • The chatbot would then grade the traffic and send coupons
  • With 80% open rate on messenger chatbots you get good sales

The Strategy

  • Strategy took 2 months to build – should have been 2-3 days
  • Spent 3-4 weeks researching Influencers, their followers, etc
  • Got 30 really good influencers with 10k to 100k followers

Finding Influencers

  • Found that using software was not as good as manual searching
  • Looked for hashtags they wanted and tracked the influencers around those
  • Researched their followers and content
  • Mass emailed them or DMd them on Instagram
  • Got about 50% replies which were good
  • Didn’t want to pay for it
  • Maybe 2-3 out of 30 will be rock stars
  • Gave them a free product but no pay


  • Send every influencer one unit of each products before the stock landed at Amazon
  • Gave them time to get their content ready
  • Got the listing live and ready to launch on Tuesday
  • Instagram Influencer would create a story or add with the deal and a discount with a link
  • Link to an AMZ promoter page
  • The page then clicked through to the Messenger chatbot
  • They are then talking to the bot
  • A really cheap and effective way to get people into the bot

Grading Traffic using the Chatbot

  • People hit the bot and if they are not time wasters they go to the end and are the ones you want to reach out to
  • If they are time wasters, they have a couple of conversations with the bot and are then forgotten

Launch Day

  • Staring at the computer on Launch Day Tuesday
  • The Influencers are primed to do the launch with their unboxing videos and pictures content
  • A lot of them were stories – you need about 10k followers to run a story
  • The story links to the product
  • They primed their audience a few days earlier really well
  • Every influencer had their own unique links to track it
  • Watching the traffic numbers and clicks
  • After 2 months they only made 1 sale


  • The volume coming from the influencers with average follower counts of 15k
  • Expected a lot of traffic to come through
  • The clicks were in the tens not hundreds
  • Then nothing
  • Only got 4 people go into the bot
  • Not got enough data to even analyse what happened

The Message

  • What was the message from the unboxing?
  • The Influencers told their audience it was 40% off
  • Some said 80% to mix it up
  • Didn’t get enough data to suss it out

What went wrong?

  • The Influencers are in engagement pods where they group up with their friends and like and click on each others posts
  • Their numbers looked great with high follower counts and clicks
  • BUT…the clicks were not ‘high converting’ clicks
  • So the strategy failed at the first step because the Influencer traffic was not high-converting and didn’t really enter the funnel in any numbers


  • Can’t sleep at night as this strategy didn’t work – it just has to work as Paul is stubborn
  • The fault was that the wrong influencers were selected
  • The next round is for the Influencers to create content and videos and it’s really good from Instagram
  • This content is then on the website and social
  • Lost 15 product units and gained a ton fo content
  • So strategy is now to go for a single really good Influencer and test out their traffic first before entering into paid collaborations for them to become Paul’s Instagram marketer
  • Should have failed faster – took too long putting it all together
  • Could have saved 6 to 8 weeks of time
  • Test it with a few before scaling it out
  • Instagram takes time to grow the audience and it’s a one-shot promotion


Make your VOTE count!

Your community needs you!

We will be in touch shortly with further details. Don't for get to share this page with the community.

Share This
%d bloggers like this: